2026年11月15日日曜日

TOEFL iBT Writing for an Academic Discussion Dormitory Roommates (Revised)

 

Would you rather have the university assign roommates, or would you prefer to choose your own? (Education)

 

 

 

☆Let’s Think

Have you ever lived with a roommate? Was the choice made by the school or was it your own? Was it successful? Why/Why not? Share your answers with others.

 

 

☆Hints for Points

1.        Randomness may bring interesting experiences. It may also make me mature.

2.        I would like to make friends with many different people and understand them.

3.        College life is to interact with various people to expand your horizon.

4.        If there should be any problem, the dormitory office can coordinate the rearrangement.

5.        I do not want to let other people decide who I should live with.

6.        University may either put the same kind of people together or the other way around. Either way will make some students unhappy.

7.        I would choose my best friends as my roommates for good memories and would do things we can only do during college years like discussing all night every day.

8.        Choosing roommates will help make the best environment for study.

9.        I would rather live with people who are similar to me because it would stabilize my college life.

10.     I would rather be with quiet and kind people.

 

 

☆Sample Answer Structures


A          

【My choice】

【My idea about college life】

【University’s choice】

【Conclusion】

 

B

【My choice】

【Good point 1】

【Good point 2】

【Bad points and why I do not care】

【Conclusion】


 

☆ Samples for Ideas and Expressions

A

【My choice】Like Ben, I find it exciting to meet new people, but when it comes to roommates of a university dormitory, I would rather choose them by myself.

【Supporting details (My idea about dorm life)】Living in a dorm room is a precious experience which will be a lifetime treasure. Whether it is possible or not depends on whether the roommates are your friends or the arranged. Dorm life with arranged roommates may end up just sharing the space and having small talks once in a while unless they are miraculously compatible with you. Even if you match, it takes a while to open up to each other. With roommates you already know well, you can start a fulfilling dorm life on day one.

【Counterargument-treatment】I know that networking is important. As Ben says, unexpected friendships will expand your life. However, networking can be done outside of dorms. In classes and in club houses, you can acquaint yourself with attractive and exciting people, but they are very often not the type you can stand being with for more than a few hours. It is preferable that roommates are people I can spend time with forever.

【Conclusion】After all, a dormitory room is a half-private space. It is fundamentally a place for rest and recharge, a space for reflection and development, and thus sharing the room with people I can be naturally on good terms with would be the best. (200 words)

 

B

【My choice】I prefer to choose my roommates because the university assignment can be racist.

【Supporting details (My concern about letting the school choose)】As I am a Japanese, they may make me join other Asian students. Although I have no problem with sharing a room with other Asians, this is different from what I expect in my dorm life. I would like to live with people from non-Asian countries to experience totally different values, mindset, and customs from mine and would like to make efforts for mutual understanding.

【Counterargument-treatment】University officials may think it for the good of Asians to stay together in a non-Asian country, but this is not what they are supposed to assume. Indeed, living with other Asians would be comfortable because we have a lot in common, but the comfort can prevent me from going out and mingling with people with different backgrounds.

【Conclusion】Universities should not decide which students should hang out together. Thus, I would rather choose my roommates myself. (142 words)


Write your draft. Then read each other’s draft, asking questions and making counterarguments.

 

                                                   DRAFT

 

 

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

                                                                                                                          

2026年11月9日月曜日

上智大学国際教養学部公募推薦英文エッセイ講座評価基準

上智大学国際教養学部入試論述問題の採点基準は公表されていませんが、一般に模擬テストは7割が合格ラインと言われているので当講座で扱う英文エッセイの評価も7割(70%)を及第点に設定し、5項目10段階評価で 7/10を及第点として合計点(50点満点)をパーセンテージに置き換えています。例えば、5項目の合計点が35/50の場合は70%になります。

以下は、5項目(Grammar, Vocabulary, Question-relevancy, Structure, Originality/Details)を佐々木個人が評価する際の基準です。実際の合否と結び付けて考えず、答案の改善に活用していただければと思います。

 

 

Grammar (文法・表現力)

7-10       文法はノーミス(ネイティブスピーカーにもあるミスは許容)、 表現力により加点

6           冠詞、3単元のs、複数のs、句読点の付け忘れ等残念なミスがある

5           構文ミスが一つある

文法問題で出題される種類のミスがある

              ミスの例: 並時制、列、関係詞、数、冠詞、態、品詞、動詞と目的語の組み合わせ等

3-4        構文ミスが複数ある

0-2        判読不能な文がある

 

Vocabulary(語彙)

8-10      文語・長めの単語の使用(使用頻度により加点)

7           平易な英語でノーミス

6           残念なスペルミス(冠詞のanがunになる等)1~2個

5           以下スペルミスの数により減点

 

Question-relevancy( 問いに対して適切な回答になっているかどうか)

8-10      主張が質問に対する答えとして適切で複数の視点があり具体例が複数ある

7           主張が質問に対する答えとして適切で複数の視点があり具体例がひとつある

2-6        主張が質問に対する答えとして適切だが、以下のいずれかまたは複数の点で問題がある

・問題意識が足りない

・複数の視点がない(必要な反論処理がない)

・具体例がない

・主張しきれていないか表現が稚拙

・誤読、逸脱、説明不足などがある

1            主張が質問に対する答えとして不適切、不明確または判読不能

0           無回答

 

Structure (構成)

・Question-relevancyが構成面で反映されている場合Question-relevancyと同じ評価

・構成上のミスがある場合Question-relevancyから減点

           構成上のミスの例:

・【主張→根拠】の流れになっていない

・不要な部分がある

・解答欄からはみ出している等

 

Originality/Details(個性/詳細)

8-10    主張に沿った具体例が複数ある

常識を踏まえたうえで感銘を与える

これまでの体験や教養、情緒の繊細さが滲み出ている。

7           主張に沿った例がひとつ挙げられている

2-6        以下のいずれかまたは複数の点で問題がある

・具体例がない

・例が主題に沿っていない

・視野が狭い(他人の立場になって考えていない等)

・知識が足りない(常識的な情報の欠如がある)

・想像だと推察される例が挙げられている(非現実的な例や引用元への言及がない等)

1           判読不能

0           無回答